Sunday, March 21, 2010

Politics of Aid


The ramifications of the BBC world service report on the distribution of aid during the Ethiopian famine in the early eighties, shows no sign of abating. With the very public clash between Rageh Omar and Bob Geldof taking place last week in the Guardian, Sunday newspapers carried articles of how Bob Geldof has demanded the heads of the BBC personnel involved with the report.

Understandably Bob Geldof is upset. For millions of us, he epitomised the efforts to save millions of starving women and children and probably put the whole concept of aid and international charity giving into a public arena. I know for me, it was one of the first instances which motivated me to get involved in humanitarian work and is one of the reasons I hold Bob Geldof in the highest of regards.

However, I feel that in this instance, he should not feel too bad. Of course the inference of the numbers actually making it to the recipients hands is something that does need to be investigated particularly as people gave in good faith, but the fact of the matter is that you cannot divorce aid from politics and that in some ways there is some element of truth to the reports. Having lived in Ethiopia, it was an open secret that some of ‘Live Aid’ was used by all sides in the conflict to sustain and prolong the war. And unfortunately, this is not and will not be first time this has happened. As many current and former aid workers will tell you, you have to deal and engage with this reality on the ground and sometimes, the engagement is about tacit support whether you like it or not.

The fact that aid agencies are ‘apolitical’ has been made even more difficult by the war against Saddam Hussain's Iraq in spring 2003 which was a striking example of the mixing of military and humanitarian action. As the United States administration made clear, the military campaign aimed at bringing down the regime was to be accompanied by the delivery of humanitarian aid to win the hearts and minds of Iraqi people and make them accept the occupying force thereby changing the whole rhetoric on humanitarian relief.

Thus the sad aspect is that despite the best intentions, undoubtedly aid will become involved in politics and if you are working in regions affected by war, the politics will be dirty. This is something that everyone (particularly donors) has to realise and come to terms with. The quicker that people understand that, the less pressure will be on humanitarian organisations and individuals to deal with the consequences.

So the question should be ‘when is it alright for this to happen and when is it not?’ This is where the confusion creeps in. There seems to be a mixed response to this internationally.

Agencies who used to work in the former ‘uncleared areas’ in Sri Lanka controlled by the Tamil Tigers will tell you that they had to deal with a separate administration, pay separate taxes and in effect had to prop up the LTTE administration despite the banning of the LTTE as a terrorist organisation internationally, if they wanted to get aid into the areas of need. Yet very few of them have been castigated internationally for doing so.

The story is very different for those organisations working in Palestine in particular Gaza. In this context organisations doing the same thing and working and dealing with different aspects of the Hamas administration such as hospitals or schools have been sidelined for supporting ‘terrorism’.

So there needs to be a change in the attitude and a consistency in approach. This is not about casting aspersions on the majority of humanitarian agencies who work without any agenda just trying to accomplish their mission of getting aid to the most neediest of people. They have to work under the most difficult and trying of circumstances and need to be supported. In recent times, despite the best efforts of ensuring transparency and accountability, aid organisations will inevitably face the challenge of working in politically complex situations. It is important for governments to ensure that these systems and regulations are in place to allow these organisations to work freely and fairly.

Ultimately aid doesn’t recognise borders and institutions and as such should be allowed to be as apolitical as possible not withstanding the political realities and complexities on the ground. Whilst the BBC report was disturbing and does need to be clarified, it does highlight the challenges faced by many people and organisations and highlights the need for the naiveté that exists in charity giving to be shed. Ultimately, Bob Geldof should take heart from this incident, that once again he has highlighted to the public the immense challenge in not only ensuring that money is raised and spent but that it is also intertwined with the political realities of the day. This education is invaluable and serves as a good reminder to all of us of the problems and challenges faced on a daily basis on the ground by those courageous aid workers forced to take difficult decisions. As such our support does not waver but in fact it grows.

Sunday, February 14, 2010

Lesson in Compassion


Robin Sharma once said that 'every person that you meet every day is a teacher of sorts'. I never truly appreciated what he meant by that, until the other night, coming back on the tube, a young man in his early twenties threw up in front of me, just narrowly avoiding my shoe but making a mess on the floor around him. The people around him quickly got up and moved to the other side of the carriage or even into another carriage. Somehow, without thinking I followed them but felt uneasy. I looked back and saw this poor guy who was clearly feeling unwell and slightly embarrassed with his head down, vomit around him and on his clothes. For about 5 minutes he was like this as people entering the tube saw him and moved away.

That is until a lady walked in with her grocery shopping, saw the mess and young man and without a moment's hesitation, went down and sat next to him. She offered him a tissue to wipe himself off, spread her newspaper that she was carrying on the floor to cover the vomit and gave him a drink and a shopping bag in case the guy would throw up again. She then proceeded to talk to the young man and you could see his mood lift.

In that split second, I realised with humility that this lady and young man had taught me a valuable lesson. The lesson of compassion and love for a fellow human being. I became and still remain ashamed that I did not do what that lady did. To rise above the pettiness and arrogance of the material world and go to the aid of someone in need. This for me was the greatest test of spirituality than anything else.

You see most of us who are from one faith or another, boast about how great our faith is. We look down on others because they are somehow less religious than us. However what this lady did is a great lesson for all of those who profess to have faith and to be practitioners of that faith. We remain intellectually arrogant when we talk about the virtues of charity and caring that our particular faith preaches. However when push comes to shove, how much do we actually put it into practice? Of course, it is one thing to give in charity or volunteer for a good cause. Yet the true nature of realising our spirituality and closeness to the Creator is when unexpected circumstances arise and we are forced to react without any premeditation. This is the ultimate test of our closeness with the Creator and our strength in our faith. How do we react? Do we remember God? Do we act in a way that is pleasing to Him? In a saying of the Prophet Mohammed (peace be upon him) it is said that 'God will tell man on the day of Judgement, that I was ill and you did not look after me. Man will respond, how can you be ill oh God? to which God will reply, such and such of my servants was ill and you did not look after him' and so on.

This brings me to the second lesson that I learned that night. That is I finally understood the concept of compassion. I have been struggling with the concept of compassion ever since I heard about Karen Armstrong's Charter for Compassion. I could never truly reconcile the theoretical aspects of compassion as outlined in religious scriptures and daily practice. She says that 'Compassion impels us to work tirelessly to alleviate the suffering of our fellow creatures, to dethrone ourselves from the centre of our world and put another there, and to honour the inviolable sanctity of every single human being, treating everybody, without exception, with absolute justice, equity and respect'. What does this mean?

That night, that lady taught me the true meaning of compassion 'do unto others as you would like them to do unto you'. In that split second I recognised that compassion is about the ability to put ourselves in other people’s shoes and to “experience with” the other.

If we reconcile ourselves with religious scriptures like the bible for example, where we are reminded in Isiah 58 6-7 to loosen the bonds of wickedness and to undo the heavy burdens, to let the oppressed go free, to share your bread with the hungry, and that you bring to your house the poor who are cast out; when you see the naked, that you cover him or what the Prophet Mohammed (peace be upon him) said “You shall not enter Paradise until you have faith, and you cannot have faith until you love one another. Have compassion on those you can see, and He Whom you cannot see will have compassion on you”.

Then we see that a world which makes sense, is a world in which we connect with other people, often beyond our immediate communities and experience, and show them compassion and love with our neighbours.

The Prophet (peace be upon him) said that ‘no one is a believer if you go to bed whilst your neighbor is hungry’ “Feeding the empty stomachs 40 doors to the right and left' The parable of the Good Samaritan also addresses this tricky issue of “who is my neighbour”, concluding that it has nothing to do with belonging to the same community or ethnic group or class but everything to do with compassion and mercy.

So where does this leave me with the lesson that I learnt that night? Compassion is about the grander things. it is about respecting and accepting the humanity of people. it is about doing something with no expectation of a return. I suddenly recalled a verse from the Qur'an (92:18-21) where God says 'Those who spend their wealth for increase in self-purification and have in their minds no favour from anyone for which a reward is expecting in return, but only the desire to seek for the Countenance of their Lord Most High, and soon will they attain complete satisfaction'. In an era of secularism, consumption and materialism, this is quite a difficult concept to fathom.

The third lesson I learnt? Every day, life will send you windows of opportunity. Your destiny will be defined by whether you choose to open the windows. Compassion is not about the big things. It is about the little things. It is about responding to whoever is in need, without a moment's thought, because they are in trouble and as a brother / sister in humanity, you have to help them. This ultimately is the teaching of all great scriptures.

Monday, January 25, 2010

Will there be a change in Sri Lanka?


On the 26th of January, Sri Lankans will be heading to the polls to elect a new President. Given the pre poll violence that has overshadowed the campaign so far, it is evident that this has not only been one of the most bloodiest elections in recent history but it is also evident that the results will be carefully monitored both local and internationally.

Yet the process of elections in Sri Lanka is a superficial attempt to paint a picture of democracy in action. For the last 60 plus years, the two main parties between themselves have held power with very little difference in policy, approach and effect. There has been a trend of ‘political upmanship’ where the main opposition party would wreck attempts by the party in power to ensure that the country would not benefit from decisive decisions made at critical junctures. As a consequence,when rival parties came to power, they tended to undo what has been done by the previous opposition government much to the detriment of the country.

Hence, this election rather than focussing on policies or issues or anything of substance, ability and reality, has boiled down to how many false promises, allegations and counter allegations can be made to convince the naïve voter. Support has thus been garnered based on much one can get out of each candidate, and so there have been crossovers and counter crossovers (from each party) like musical chairs, as ‘horse deals’ ensure that politicians and their supporters needs are met.

The politics of Sri Lanka is actually a Shakespearean comedy of errors. Where else would you find one of the chief architects of the final conflict pitted against its chief engineer? Where else would you find almost laughable unholy alliances? For example, you have the JVP, who are seen as a Sinhalese Nationalist party, pitted with the very party who brutally crushed them in the 1980s, against the very man and party they helped to bring to power in 2005. Then, the headlines were very different as President Rajapkase was accused of being a Sinhalese hardliner. Circumstances have now changed and former allies have become enemies and former enemies have become allies with accusations being thrown between the two sometimes bordering on the point of absurdity in some cases.

Yet this kind of unsubstantiated cross-vilifcation is not just the past time of the candidates and their key backers. It seems to be an affliction of the ordinary Sri Lankan who has the uncanny ability to pick up lies and spread them around, often adding their own creative spices to the mix. The result is a ‘Chinese Whispers’ game of immense magnitude.

There seems to be very little appetite for any intellectual analysis of the situation on the part of the general public, especially those that live in Colombo, which is as far removed from the realities of the country as it can be. Everyone is advocating for a change, tired of the cost that the conflict has inflicted upon the nation, tired of the corruption of the political system, tired of how Sri Lanka has become as a nation and society. But you dig a little deeper and you notice that frankly despite all the illusions of grandeur, nothing will change. Speaking to people in Sri Lanka, there are only two camps. Those who want the incumbent and those who want the main opposition candidate with very little room in between. There is not really a middle pat h or alternative and no avenue for a middle path, as the recent violence at the polls have shown. Those that advocate it are a silent majority on the sidelines. Yet dig further and you will find that people have absolutely no clue as to why one should vote for the incumbent or the opposition. ‘Well we need to get rid of Mahinda so that is why we want Sarath’ has been the most common argument that I have heard. ‘Mahinda liberated the country from war and Sarath is a traitor’ has been the other one. No one talks about the policies.What of their policies? How are they going to take the country forward?

Of course, because no matter who wins the presidency, he will have an uphill struggle on his hands. First there will be the task of resettling all the displaced people from the 20 years of war, and focussing on rebuilding the war torn north and east. There will be the task of ensuring a political solution to the grievances of the minorities in a way that ensures that the country moves forward after 20 years of conflict. There will be a need to contain the Sinhalese Buddhist elements who seem intent on hammering the Sinhala nationalist identity home. However more importantly there will be the task of arresting the moral and intellectual corruption that seems to not pervade the political scene but has also seemed to have trickled down into society as a whole. Yet neither of the main candidates has presented a clear proposal for the reconciliation and integration of the society.

This then begs the question; will there be a change if the main opposition candidate is voted in ahead of the incumbent? Whilst a new face will get into the driving seat, the vehicle and direction will be the same. The paradigm will not have shifted!

Therefore the concept of being ‘principled’ by picking either the incumbent or the main contender becomes laughable. Both these candidates and the parties and alliance they represent are two sides of the same coin and at this critical juncture in Sri Lanka’s history may not be able to offer anything of value for taking the country forward especially as it moves towards post conflict reconciliation and reconstruction. Picking either one of them would be at best, frantically grasping for a last minute consolation prize and it would be based on a limited understanding of the ground realities and ingrained prejudices. There will be nothing pure or principled about the choice.

If people want to make a principled choice and vote for ‘change’, then there will need to be a paradigm shift . Variations on the same old themes should not be the order of the day. They will have to make a radical choice on the candidate that they choose. There are 18 other candidates in the running, but are all dismissed, because they have no chance of winning. This is not the point. The point is that you vote for an alternative because you want this change without compromising your principles. Some commentators have even advocated to spoil the vote, if you can not find a decent candidate who voices the concerns of those without voice or those whose have been robbed of voice or have had their voices purchased . This might seem to some a bit extreme but under the circumstances in Sri Lanka, extreme measures are called for.

Regardless of who wins in the election, no one doubts that now is the time for reconciliation. Petty rivalries will need to be forgotten. Past grievances will need to be looked into and addressed. This requires the support of all concerned from within Sri Lanka and outside of it.

Monday, October 26, 2009

After 26 years of war that cost thousands of innocent lives, the defeat of the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) has brought Sri Lanka to a crossroads. Yet despite the government's victory, there has been widespread international criticism about how the war was handled. Success has come at a price in terms of destruction, death and the displacement of civilians. The number of actual deaths during the conflict, particularly in its last days, will never be known, despite many international attempts to hold the Sri Lankan government to task.
Despite the LTTE being widely praised in the Tamil diaspora as a "freedom fighting" organisation, it was one of the world's worst terrorist groups. It had perfected the art of suicide bombing and assassination, as well as engaging in the massacre of civilians from all communities, including Sinhalese and Tamils, and the ethnic cleansing of Muslim civilians from the north in 1990.
Reconstruction, resettlement and rehabilitation will be the immediate postwar challenges and will have to be expertly handled. Reconstruction of infrastructure will be the easiest and most attractive option for donors, but creating an environment of equity and social justice could be relegated to the bottom of the list. There must be a separate effort to ensure reconciliation between people. Many barriers have been erected between Sri Lanka's communities and special programmes to build bridges, facilitate interfaith interaction and regain intercommunity trust are urgently required.
This is the role that the Sri Lankan diaspora as a whole will need to play to bring about a reconciliation that combines human values with an understanding of the need to move away from apportioning blame. Rebuilding trust will mean honouring unity and celebrating diversity, working towards equity and justice and ensuring the eradication of social prejudices in building a collective identity.
Elements of the Tamil diaspora, in particular, have been active in sustaining the conflict. Some are still trying to keep the cause alive by exerting pressure on the international community to instigate war crimes proceedings or cut back on trade subsidies such as the EU's generous tariff preference, the GSP+.
However, they fail to realise that this will not harm the government and will be detrimental to the overall development of the country. Cutting tariff preferences, for example, will affect industry – which will in turn affect the livelihoods of all communities. Ultimately, taking a government to task should be done through a normal democratic process, which can only work if all elements within the country work towards that goal. The focus now has to be on the future development of the country.
How Sri Lanka handles the current displacement crisis is likely to determine the confidence of its minorities and the diaspora. Pressure is mounting for quick resettlement and to give Tamils a share of power. To this end the government will have to work to ensure that all people feel they are equal citizens with equal rights.
Addressing the Sri Lankan parliament last May, President Mahinda Rajapaksa said: "We have removed the word 'minorities' from our vocabulary." Sadly, people seemed to have brushed aside the president's statement as a gimmick, claiming that he himself does not believe in it and has no clear plans for the future. Without denying past grievances, there should now be a move to hold the government to task in terms of building confidence among the various communities and giving ownership to the minorities in rebuilding the country.
The Tamils believed that they were fighting for an identity and to control their own affairs. Such feelings cannot be blotted out by eliminating the LTTE but they can be made irrelevant by the treatment Tamils (and other minorities) receive in the new Sri Lanka. There should now be an active and systematic campaign for celebrating coexistence among Sri Lanka's diverse communities – and the Sri Lankan diaspora can play a big part in it.


This originally appeared here

Monday, October 19, 2009

Challenges of the Monsoon


The recent announcement by the UK government that it would only concentrate on ‘emergency’ funding for the inhabitants at Manik Farm has been designed to exert pressure on the Sri Lankan government to develop some solid and sustainable settlement to the issue of the 300,000 plus IDPs after the end of the conflict with the LTTE in April. 

Since the end of April, these refugees have been in these camps  with the most basic of needs found wanting.  If you had read any of my previous blogs you would have read about the challenges faced by these people as well as those working within the camps, the situation not being helped by a reluctance of the government to open up.  Understandably though as there is this incessant government paranoia of ‘having no friends’.

 However with the onset of the monsoon season producing the bigger threat of flooding and water borne diseases, the government, camp authorities as well as the humanitarian community are faced with a bigger dilemma.  How do we sort this out?  How do we deal with a potentially even bigger problem?

The fault is borne by everyone. Unfortunately like previous governments before it, there was a knee jerk reaction by the government to the issue of the IDPs (largely brought about in response to international pressure) when it committed itself to the 180 day resettlement notice.  For many of us on the ground, we felt that this was too premature and not feasible, given the extent of the displacement and the damage done (both mentally and physically).  Just look at the challenges that are being faced by those that are returning to Mannar or even the east after hostilities ceased there? 

Hence what it was felt was needed was a planned approach where all stakeholders were involved.  Unfortunately this has and is not taking place as the government is wary of any outside interference. The humanitarian agencies are not being consulted as they should be primarily because they have lost the confidence of the government.

The humanitarian community is also to blame for the current fiasco in terms of the basic conditions in the camps.  Most of us knew the unrealistic nature of the resettlement plan and we have also privately discussed how it is not possible to move people back into the areas immediately after displacement.  Yet publicly most of us kept on pushing for quick resettlement and an end to the camps. Some of us in fact opposed it from day one, putting great suspicions on our motives, intentions and objectivity.

Most agencies argued with the issue of semi permanent vs temporary (see my blog on the issue of the toilets) whilst knowing that any solution should realistically in fact be medium term.  This is the natural cycle of any post disaster reconstruction and resettlement.  Just look at the issue of tsunami victims in the east who are still in refugee camps yet to receive any support for long term settlements.  Knowing this we campaigned for something else and accused the government of something else, in the firm realisation that the government would react in the way that they did.  Hence the vicious cycle was perpetuated and the political tennis match continues.

Somehow, there should have been a middle point that we arrived at in terms of accepting a medium term situation, preparing for this and ensuring that the beneficiaries got the best that we could offer them. There should have been this will to move towards this in order to develop a better confidence and relationship with the government as opposed to dictating terms.

Of course the issue of ‘internment’ and security was something that we could have also met halfway with the government had there been an open mind and situation to discuss this. 

However at the end of the day, the monsoons will come, the camp inhabitants will suffer from floods and whatever else that comes with floods and it will be left up to the government and humanitarian agencies to try and cope with this, each side throwing accusations against each other on responsibilities.  The vicious cycle will continue.

As for the long term solution, the planning has to take place now.  The current situation is very unsustainable from all accounts.  Despite there being a need for security to be preserved, the camps will need to be made more open and downsized.  It will make them more manageable.  The sustainability of the operations has to be considered in this regard. Of course, we have to realise that the resettlement will not really take place properly for another year or so.  The logistics, challenges and financial constraints are just too much to even consider.  So what does this mean?

There needs to be this discussion that takes place.  The humanitarian community need to  push for this and if there is international pressure to be mounted on the Sri Lankan government, it should be on this issue, to engage in a holistic and inclusive planning for resettlement and rehabilitation.  This is the priority at the moment.  Any other issue is tantamount to a distraction and will not help those most in need.  

Monday, August 17, 2009

Challenges for Sri Lanka


Sri Lanka is certainly in the midst of a paradoxical situation.  You would not be far wrong to surmise that depending on where you visit, you will see different aspects of Sri Lanka that makes you wonder whether you are in the same country or not.

If you are in Colombo you would no doubt be enjoying watching the finer aspects of cricket as Sri Lanka entertains visiting teams from  Pakistan and New Zealand.  Go down south and you would have experienced one of many marathon beach parties that have taken place to entertain the many summer visitors that flock annually to Sri Lanka’s shores.  In the central province of Kandy, the annual  Esala Perehera  (a  Buddhist festival unique to Sri Lanka consisting of dances and richly-decorated elephants) came to an end a few weeks ago and other smaller Pereheras have also started to wind down.  In the northern parts of Sri Lanka, election fever was rising as candidates campaigned for the first time in a long time in local government elections, one of many anticipated for this year in a run up to early presidential elections perhaps in 2010.   Despite the poor showing at the polls, people (mainly the government) still were buoyed by the fact that they took place. As the IMF loan  begins to trickle into the  country there certainly seems to be an upbeat mood, as imports are trickling back in and the tourists are heading back to the shores.

However this positive energy is tempered by a sudden dose of reality as one realizes the true challenges facing the country.  The residents of Manik Farm in Vavunia are now entering the third month after the defeat of the LTTE.  The chaos of the initial months have now disappeared and a system has been established for running the camps.  The problems of the toilets are still there and food is sometimes inadequate.  The medical needs are tremendous and there are still challenges for proper access to the camps by agencies, particularly those where there are foreigners.  There is still a little bit of confusion when it comes to the smooth operations of the camp and coordination is proving to be an arch nemesis. Hence there are some agencies that are choosing to coordinate with each other in what is called ‘cluster groups’ whilst others are choosing to work on their own or directly with the government.  Individuals / locals though seem to have better access into the camps and it has been heartening to hear of few stories of individuals helping out the best way they can.  The worry now is that as the monsoon season approaches, flooding will occur.  Already, over the weekend, floods caused the ‘temporary’ resettling of 400 residents in one of the zones in Manik Farm.

Another challenge is the final resettlement of the people who have been displaced.  The amount of investment that would be required for such a feat is still uncertain, but it needs to be given a priority.  The execution of this needs to be done in a well thought out manner.  Whilst some resettlement is already taking place and there was a token opening of the A9 road to Jaffna, there is still a lot of uncertainty as to the process of resettlement.  This process can’t just be for political gain but will need to involve real consultation at all levels to ensure reconciliation.

The real big challenge though is keeping these issues news worthy as it appears that the vast majority of the public seem to have forgotten the plight of the people.  As the news has slipped from the front pages of the newspapers or the headlines on the TV, so has the awareness of the plight of the displaced.  One reporter at a dinner the other day was remarking on how difficult they were finding it to obtain news for their broadsheets.  It seems that the war was good business at least in terms of paper sales.  When I asked him what about reconciliation and reconstruction and the pledge of the government to tackle minority issues, he remarked wryly, ‘let us wait and see’.  And so this is perhaps the mood of the norm.  ‘Let us wait and see what the President or the Government does’.  No one seems to be willing to take the first step; No one is even bothered about the historical significance of the President’s statement ‘There are no more minorities’.  People I have talked to are just apathetic enough to wait for the politicians to come up with something rather than taking the challenge up themselves. How does one go about ensuring the eradication of ‘minorities’ from their vocabulary?

There are enormous challenges at all levels in Sri Lanka: micro / meso / macro.  Some of the challenges are inter and intra ethnicity and faith.

Take for example, the clashes between rival mosques in southern Sri Lanka a couple of weeks ago which turned bloody leaving scores dead and injured or the incident where police were accused of attacking people on the pretext of searching for terrorists or members of the underworld or the supposed impunity and liberty that people are still accusing the armed forces of behaving with. These incidents serve to underline simmering tensions that exist under the surface. 

These tensions are to do with economics, deprivation, poverty; ignorance and lack of understanding.  What is important to realise is that whilst this may be in existence within communities, it also exists between communities and will need to be addressed.  People are still talking about the challenges facing  ‘their’ community be it Tamil or Muslim or any other.  There is still no sense of a collective identity.  What is sad is that people have abrogated their individual responsibility to do something about it.

The new fight that Sri Lanka now faces is not of  minority issues (although this is also important) but addressing equitable distribution of resources so everyone benefits.  This is the path towards ensuring a new collective resolution to solving the country’s issues.



Thursday, July 2, 2009

slum dwellers


You know there is a saying that ‘you can’t see the forest because of the trees’.  I have often wondered about that statement and applauded the guy who came up with it.  Because it is true!! Often we are so used to seeing what is in front of us that we rarely step back and admire the greater picture.

Over the last couple of months, we have been so engrossed in the humanitarian crisis that is currently affecting Sri Lanka that nothing else is as important.  The news and the blogs have been awash with claims and counter claims  as the battle has spread to cyberspace.  As aid agencies, it has been easy to get caught up in the immediate disaster that very often, other equally pressing needs have been overlooked or pushed down the priority list.  As the displaced get all the attention and focus, those who are equally in need without much attention get forgotten.

The urban poor are by themselves a separate entity.  The ‘forgotten people’ as I called them once in a previous blog.  Equally deserving of our attention yet getting a minute fraction of it during normal times, during emergencies, the attention given to them is nil.  I heard stories during the tsunami of beggars in Colombo making the journey east or south wards to get what was being handed out to tsunami survivors, purely because no one was giving them in Colombo.

I bring this up because recently I had to pay a visit to one of the slums in Colombo where one of the beneficiaries of our child support program was living.  The child’s mother had suddenly died and we were there to pay our respects.  Visiting there after having visited the camps in Vavunia was an eye opener for me.

Slums in Colombo are probably like any other developing country’s capital, although the city displayed in Slum Dog Millionaire is probably one of the extreme types.  Houses are cramped close together and you will find people of all faiths and ethnicities living peacefully and in a sense of co-existence and dependency.  We have often debated that in order for us to develop our conflict resolution program; we should actually consult the people in the urban slums since they seem to have got the right form.

The defining thing about the slums is that whilst people may have houses or what can be described as houses, there is often poor sanitation and water facilities.  So toilets and bathing facilities are common and it is not rare to see people cooking, washing clothes and bathing on the road.  During the rainy season, inevitablby it becomes a fast flowing flood of raw sewage down the road and into your house.  If you are unlucky to be living in areas that always get flooded, every year, without fail, you will suffer from flooding or worse, your house may be built on marshy land which means 365 days a year, you are water logged.

Visiting this child’s house where there were a few possessions lying around, I was struck by the sheer hopelessness of the situation.  This child and his sister and mother were living in what could be described as a two bedroom place, except that the bedroom was in the kitchen and the living room doubled up as another bedroom, dining room and store room.  I am not even sure where the bathroom was.  The mother had died suddenly and here were these two kids without anyone to fend for them.  Their mother had been a day labourer just making ends meet whilst their father was a three wheel taxi driever who had been murdered about 4 years ago.  So there was nothing for them.  No house or investment or estate or $500 million legacy left to them as had been left to now the world famous orphans.

These people were living in abject poverty, rarely making ends meet, not being able to eat 3 square meals or getting the benefit of a proper childhood.  Our child sponsorship program was able to help them make ends meet with additional food and health checks and support for education.  So in this sense these particular kids were lucky.  However if you take the majority of children living under these conditions, then this would be their plight.  Open to crime or any other vices, the kids don’t seem to have a very rosy future.  In fact very few of them make it past high school before they start fending for themselbes.

The sad fact is that these kids and families are not less needy than those in the north and the east.  To some extent, the families who have been displaced by war or disaster are often luckier because they receive assistance from organisations like ours and they are on the government list.  The urban poor operate beyond the radar and out of sight.  It is very hard to get humanitarian agencies to work in these areas since it is not their mandate.  It is the mandate of the government or local civil society.

That said I am sure I will get various arguments for and against this blog.  My intention is not to spark a debate over politics or what agencies should and should not do.  It is more to reflect and revisit.  The needs are great to empower and uplift people from poverty.  Poverty is multidimensional with many faces.  Thus it requires many different approaches and ideas.  When we think about the needy in the camps in vavunia, let us also not forget those who live down our street or in our cities, for they are as equally in need.  Whilst we individually or collectively may not be able to influence or support what is happening in the north, this doesn’t mean that we can’t do something for those who we can help. I can’t help but make this final statement but at the end of the day   if you want to make the world a better place, take a look at yourself and make that change